Physical Activity With and Without Arm Sleeves: Compliance and Quality of Life After Breast Cancer Surgery—A Randomized Controlled Trial

Katarzyna Ochalek, PhD, PT,1,2 Tomasz Gradalski, PhD, MD, 2 Zbigniew Szygula, PhD, MD, 3 and Hugo Partsch, PhD, MD4. Lymphatic Research and Biology December 2017

Click to read the abstract

Physical Activity With and Without Arm Sleeves: Compliance and Quality of Life After Breast Cancer Surgery—A Randomized Controlled Trial

Katarzyna Ochalek, PhD, PT,1,2 Tomasz Gradalski, PhD, MD, 2 Zbigniew Szygula, PhD, MD, 3 and Hugo Partsch, PhD, MD4. Lymphatic Research and Biology January 2018

Background: After breast cancer surgery patients are at higher risk of lymphedema development and decreasing physical activity (PA), as well as decreasing health-related quality of life (HRQOL). The aim of the study was to compare the level of PA and HRQOL in women after breast cancer surgery using light arm compression with women not using compression 1 year after oncological treatment.

Methods and Results: Forty-five women were preoperatively randomly assigned to a compression group (CG, n=23) or to no compression group (NCG, n=22). Arm volumes were measured before surgery and 12 months thereafter. The CG received circular-knit sleeves in compression class 1 for daily wearing in the postoperative period up to 1 year. Both groups underwent a standardized physical exercise program. PA with the short version of International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ), compliance, and HRQOL by EORTC QLQ-C30 and QLQBR23 questionnaires was assessed in both groups 1 year after surgery. After 1 year observation the CG showed significantly lower mean affected arm volume compared to NCG. The total PA (calculated as the sum of vigorous moderate exercises and walking) was markedly higher within the CG, with no difference in particular IPAQ items. There were no correlations between reported PA items and observed arm/edema volume or body mass index changes. TheQLQ-BR23 revealed only better sexual functioning (p=0.014) and greater upset by hair loss in NCG (p=0.01).

Conclusions: The available data indicate that wearing compression sleeves neither interfere with the level of PA nor decrease quality of life 1 year after breast cancer surgery.

Main findings

  • Small sample size.
  • Measurements were only taken twice, that is preoperatively and 12 months post operatively.
  • In the compression group arm sleeves (not sure whether there was compression on the hand) was worn daily for 8-10 hours.
  • The reliability of their measurement method is not indicated. There was no explanation on how the circumference measurements were taken.
  • The incidence of lymphoedema at 12 months was 4/23 for the compression group and 6/22 for the non compression group.
  • With a small sample size it is unclear how the authors can claim that wearing a compression garment was able to reduce the incidence and amount of early postoperative oedema and of lymphoedema.